Categories 1942Tags

The unpopular U-boat officers from U-581

An interesting view of the Royal Navy destroyer HMS Westcott, pictured in 1943.

Not all U-Boat commanders were as resolved as [permalink id=16516 text=”Reinhard Hardegen”] of U-123.

U Boat U-581 was attacked and sunk by HMS Westcott, Cdr Ian Hamilton Bockett-Pugh, southwest of the Azores on 2nd February. Once again the German perspective of the attack was pieced together by Naval Intelligence when they interviewed the survivors:

“U 581” was in the Straits between the islands of Pico and Fayal in the early hours of 2nd February, 1942, steering a north-westerly course, when she became aware of the presence of one or more British destroyers and immediately dived.

She fired one torpedo from her stern tube at the nearer of the two destroyers, but is was admitted that it went wide of its mark. It was not yet daylight, but the moon was full. While “U 581” was submerged at a depth of about 80 metres (262.47 ft.) a rivet on the flange of her port after exhaust pipe gave way and water entered the engine room compartment. Strenuous efforts were made to control the entry of water, but these were of no avail, owing to the pressure at this depth. The entry of water aft not only made it very difficult to keep trim while submerged, but it also threatened to put the electric motors out of action.

An atmosphere of panic prevailed and “U 581” submerged to a depth of some 160 metres (524.94 ft.) involuntarily. The Commanding Officer ordered the tanks to be blown and “U 581” rose to within some 20 metres (65.61 ft.) of the surface, when the sound of the destroyers’ propellers overhead could be distinctly heard. The Engineer Officer accordingly appealed to the Captain to submerge again as he was afraid they were going to collide with the attacking craft. The Captain acceded to this request and the boat once more dived, somewhat out of control, to about 150 metres (492.13 ft.). But this was too much for the Commanding Officer’s nerves and he finally gave the order to surface.

After U-581 surfaced the attacking destroyer, H.M.S. Westcott, managed to ram her.

The crew of the U-Boat had abandoned ship a matter of some five seconds before the impact. No attempt was made to engage “Westcott” with gunfire. H.M.S. “Westcott” now prepared to carry out a second ramming, but before this could be put into effect, “U 581’s” bows rose clear of the water and she sank by the stern in over 400 fathoms.

As well as piecing together the details of attacks on U-Boats, from which they could glean very useful tactical information, Naval Intelligence sought to build up a broad picture of the operations of the U-Boat arm generally. The crew of U-581 were not a happy bunch and apparently were very ready to provide lots of information about many other U-Boats operating from their base, how successful they were and where they had been. The general morale of U-boat crews was of equal interest – and in this case the crew of U-581 proved to be very forthcoming about their pay and conditions – but not least some comments about their own officers:

Kapitänleutnant Werner Pfeifer

He had been on the friendliest terms with his Engineer Officer before the war and there is little doubt that either willingly or perhaps subconsciously he allowed himself to come under the evil influence of this man. Pfeifer gave the impression of being a casual type who had failed to take his U-Boat career very seriously. Though probably glad to have his own command, he does not seem to have been particularly energetic or enthusiastic in the pursuit of enemy shipping.

It was said of him that on one occasion, when a British destroyer had been sighted, he had excused himself with the remark: “I’ve got to go to the lavatory for a moment,” despite the entreaties of his junior officers to take offensive action. When he returned the destroyer was not in a favourable position for attack.

Such lack of enthusiasm had a depressing effect on his crew, who were not slow to show their dislike of returning to port with no pennants flying, whereas other U-Boats would usually fly several, one for each ship claimed sunk. He was stated not even to have wished his crew a merry Christmas or a happy New Year. In sharp contradistinction to some of the more popular commanding officers, he allowed no alcohol on board his boat.

Pfeifer wrote a protest about his capture, claiming that it was all a mistake – he had been in neutral waters at the time of his sinking, had not tried to torpedo anyone, and should not be a prisoner of war but be allowed to go to a neutral country.

The Engineer Officer Helmut Krummel was described as the evil genius of the boat:

If his manner under interrogation is any indication of his behaviour on board his unpopularity is not surprising. Tales were recounted of how he had forbidden the crew to listen to any music, unless he personally issued orders to this effect. Also, there was said not to be a single petty officer or man in “U 581” who had not received punishment at his hands. On one occasion a chief petty officer had threatened Krummel with personal violence in the presence of other officers. Officers from “U 93” described him as always trying to pick out the bad points in other people’s characters and to ignore the good.

Read the whole report at U Boat Archive.

11 thoughts on “The unpopular U-boat officers from U-581”

  1. My Uncle AB Leslie Sowerby served on Westcott
    And died on active service on15th June 1942. I have read he was killed by anti aircraft fire from HMS Liverpool.

  2. Hello all, I am a native of the island of Pico. I was born there and now live in Canada. I saw a Portuguese article about the sinking of U-581 and started clicking on links and looking up HMS wescot before reaching this site. I have never heard any stories from family or friends about this event. It is very intriguing to me to read all this information seeing that Pico is such a small island and to have never heard of this before… If anyone has any stories pictures or names they would like to share with me, it would be much appreciated. You can look for me on Facebook or email me at fraganator2001@yahoo.com
    Thank you in advance.

  3. U-581 was found back in September, and it’s discovery was announced today, the 75th anniversary of it’s loss.

  4. My Dad, Frank Malherbe, also joined the Westcott (as a leading stoker) in July 1943, having had been on HMS Valorous since 1941. After VE Day,he immediately left the UK for Australia on board HMS Black Prince, and wasn’t demobbed until his return home in ’46. He never really had the chance to speak to me about his experiences in the war, because he was hospitalised in 1960 & died in Feb. ’63 when I was 15. I am trying to piece together his time in the War, and would appreciate anything at all. I have a copy of Tom Chapman’s book “Water, Water, Every Where” but my Dad isn’t mentioned. Stewart

  5. I served aboard the Westcott 1943-45, we did 5 Russian convoys, 2 before “D” day and two after, despite serving on two other ships, Westcott was my first and favourite, she was very efficient and very happy, I made some life long friends and organised some reunions, and am still in contact with some of the crew members

  6. My father was a member of U581.I would like more informations. The interrogation after captured is so far away the stupid heroenarration,we know.Perhaps we can connect each othter and exchange news.I am 60 and try to tell my familyhistory to my 6 children.

  7. My father was a member of the crew of U581.Perhaps we can connect and exchange news? I am sixty years old and i would like explore my family history and tell it to my six children.My father is naturelly a part of this familyhistory.

  8. My father was a 19 year-old signalman serving on HMS Westcott at the time. I have some old photograghs taken onboard, including a few that a believe show U581 after it had been rammed and the survivors being picked up. My father held Commander Bockett-Pugh in very high regard.

  9. My Father was a 19 year-old signalman serving on HMS Wescott at the time. I have some old photographs taken onboard, including a few which I believe show U581 after it had been rammed and the surviours being picked up. My father held Commander Bockett-Pugh in very high regard.

  10. Commander Bockett-Pugh was my father. He received 3 DSO’s, one for this incident.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.